In the US drones have a built-in ID. It is not going down well with users, but the courts seems to go the FAA way:
US federal appeals court upholds Federal Aviation Administration drone identification rule
By Niamh Forgie | Auckland Law School, NZ on Jul 30, 2022 09:49 am
The US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit Friday upheld the Federal Aviation Administration’s (FAA) rule on drone identification.
Brennan v. Dickson was brought by Tyler Brennan, a drone user, and the drone equipment retailer owned by Brennan, RaceDayQuads LLC, challenging the FAA over its Remote Identification Rule of April 2021. The rule requires drone manufacturers to begin producing drones with remote ID.
Judge Cornelia Pillard, who wrote for the 3-0 panel, explained remote ID technology as requiring “drones in flight to emit publically readable radio signals reflecting certain identifying information, including their serial number, location, and performance information.” The FAA has compared remote ID to a “digital license plate.”
Brennan argued that the Remote ID rule amounted to “constant, warrantless governmental surveillance in violation of the Fourth Amendment.”
Pillard upheld the FAA rule, writing in her judgment, “Drones are coming. lots of them. They are fun and useful. But their ability to pry, spy, crash, and drop things poses real risks. Free-for-all drone use threatens air traffic, people and things on the ground, and even national security.” She struck down claims that the remote ID requirement amounted to privacy breaches and unconstitutional surveillance, stating that “drones are virtually always flown in public. Requiring a drone to show its location and that of its operator while the drone is aloft in the open air violates no reasonable expectation of privacy.”
The post US federal appeals court upholds Federal Aviation Administration drone identification rule appeared first on JURIST - News.
- Board index My Aviation Interests Drones, UAVs
-
- It is currently Mon Mar 17, 2025 12:18 am
- All times are UTC+02:00
Compulsory factory-built ID for drones
Unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV), commonly known as a drone and also referred to as an unpiloted aerial vehicle and a remotely piloted aircraft (RPA) by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), is an aircraft without a human pilot aboard.
Moderator: Moderators
1 post
• Page 1 of 1
-
- Airborne from Unmanned field
- Posts: 530
- Joined: Wed May 02, 2018 2:55 pm
- Closest Airfield: FACT
- Has thanked: 157 times
- Been thanked: 75 times
Compulsory factory-built ID for drones
Unread post by jean »
- These users thanked the author jean for the post:
- Shepherd
1 post
• Page 1 of 1
Jump to
- General Aviation
- ↳ General Aviation Chatter
- ↳ Events & Destinations
- ↳ Events
- ↳ Destinations
- ↳ Academy & Flight Safety
- ↳ Airline Chatter
- ↳ Instrument Flying
- ↳ Rotor Wing
- ↳ Gyro Chatter
- ↳ Aerobatics & Sport Flying
- ↳ Aviation medical and related issues
- ↳ Our Aircraft
- ↳ Our Register
- ↳ Building and Maintaining Aircraft
- ↳ Aircraft and Engine Type Discussions
- ↳ A22 Foxbat
- ↳ Aeronca
- ↳ Airdrome Aeroplanes
- ↳ American Champion / Bellanca
- ↳ Bat Hawk
- ↳ Bearhawk
- ↳ Beechcraft
- ↳ Boeing Stearman
- ↳ Bosbok & Kudu
- ↳ Bowers Flybaby
- ↳ Bushbaby
- ↳ CAMit Aero Engines
- ↳ Canard
- ↳ Cessna
- ↳ Cheetah
- ↳ Cirrus
- ↳ Continental Motors
- ↳ CT Aircaft
- ↳ Cubby
- ↳ Evans Volksplane
- ↳ Evektor
- ↳ FK-Lightplanes
- ↳ Glasair
- ↳ Ibis
- ↳ Jabiru
- ↳ Jabiru Engines
- ↳ Jodel
- ↳ KIS
- ↳ KR
- ↳ Lambada & Samba
- ↳ Lancair
- ↳ Lycoming Engines
- ↳ Maule
- ↳ Mooney
- ↳ MT-03 Gyroplane
- ↳ North American P-51 Mustang
- ↳ Orion Cub
- ↳ Pietenpol Air Camper
- ↳ Piper
- ↳ Pipistrel
- ↳ RANS Aircraft
- ↳ Ravin Aircraft
- ↳ Ravens
- ↳ Remos Aircraft
- ↳ Robinson Helicopters
- ↳ Rotax Aircraft Engines
- ↳ Savannah
- ↳ Scheibe Falke
- ↳ Skyleader series
- ↳ Sling
- ↳ Sonex
- ↳ Spitfire Replicas
- ↳ Taylor Monoplane and Titch
- ↳ Taylorcraft
- ↳ Tucano Replica
- ↳ UL Power Aero Engines
- ↳ Van's Aircraft
- ↳ Volkswagen
- ↳ Whisper Aircraft
- ↳ Yak
- ↳ Zenith and Zenair
- ↳ Avionics
- ↳ Dynon
- ↳ Garmin
- ↳ MGL
- ↳ Our Clubs, Groups and Organisations
- ↳ Aero Club of South Africa
- ↳ EAA of South Africa
- ↳ Soaring Society of South Africa
- ↳ Jabiru Club of South Africa
- ↳ We will remember them
- ↳ 123.45
- My Aviation Interests
- ↳ Space
- ↳ Aviation Photography
- ↳ Virtual Aviation
- ↳ Virtual Airlines
- ↳ Model Aircraft
- ↳ General Model Aircraft Chatter
- ↳ Model Events
- ↳ Scale Helicopters
- ↳ My Model Associations and SIGs
- ↳ CLASA
- ↳ Model Marketplace
- ↳ Model Personal Classifieds
- ↳ Non Aviation Items
- ↳ Community Courier
- ↳ Commercial Member Adverts
- ↳ Trader Watch
- ↳ Drones, UAVs
- ↳ Paragliding & Powered Paragliding
- Marketplace
- ↳ Personal Classifieds
- ↳ Aircraft for Sale
- ↳ Aviation Accessories
- ↳ Non aviation items
- ↳ Trader Watch
- ↳ Model Personal Classifieds
- ↳ Community Courier
- ↳ Job Centre
- ↳ Professional Recruiting Agencies
- ↳ Administration, Operations, Engineering and Other Support
- ↳ Aeroplane
- ↳ Helicopter
- ↳ Drones
- Service Providers
- ↳ SAWS
- ↳ ATNS
- ↳ CAA
- ↳ CAA General Questions
- ↳ CAA Open Door
- ↳ ICASA
- ↳ Commercial Products & Services
- Using the Forum - Tips & Tricks